Embedded Files
BANANAS FOSTER COOKIE TUTORIAL
BANANAS FOSTER COOKIE TUTORIAL
My Bestselling Sandwich Cookie for Two Years Running!
My Bestselling Sandwich Cookie for Two Years Running!
Real banana. Warm spices. Brown sugar toffee. Rum. Toasted pecans. And a gooey, silky butterscotch sauce swirled through a luscious banana rum brown sugar frosting.
All tucked between two cookies with the signature texture you know and love: crispy on the outside, soft and fudgy on the inside.
Some cookies are good. And then there are the cookies customers come back for again and again.
My Bananas Foster Sandwich Cookie has been my bestselling sandwich cookie for two years in a row, and for good reason! Inspired by the iconic New Orleans dessert, this cookie brings together layers of rich, buttery, caramelized flavor in one seriously indulgent sandwich cookie.
Now I'm sharing the recipe with you!
A COOKIE WITH LAYERS UPON LAYERS OF FLAVOR
A COOKIE WITH LAYERS UPON LAYERS OF FLAVOR
Real Banana & Warm Spices
This cookie is bursting with real banana flavor, complemented by warm spices and rich brown sugar. It's comforting, indulgent, and packed with the flavors that make Bananas Foster such a classic dessert.
Homemade Brown Sugar Toffee & Toasted Pecans
Homemade brown sugar toffee adds buttery, caramelized sweetness, while toasted pecans bring a delicious nutty flavor and texture. A touch of rum rounds out the flavors and gives this cookie its unmistakable Bananas Foster character.
Banana Rum Brown Sugar Frosting with Gooey Butterscotch
The sandwich filling takes everything to another level! A luscious banana rum brown sugar frosting is swirled with a gooey, silky butterscotch sauce, creating irresistible ribbons of buttery sweetness throughout the filling.
Every bite brings together sweet banana, warm spices, rich brown sugar, toasted pecans, rum, and silky butterscotch.
This isn't just a banana cookie. It's Bananas Foster reimagined as a gourmet sandwich cookie, with every component working together to deliver a flavor-packed bite.
And of course, you get that signature cookie texture I work so hard to achieve: crispy edges with a soft, fudgy center.
BONUS RECIPE: THE ELVIS COOKIE
BONUS RECIPE: THE ELVIS COOKIE
Because one indulgent cookie deserves another, your tutorial also includes my Elvis Cookie bonus recipe!
Inspired by the legendary combination of banana, peanut butter, and chocolate, this cookie is delicious all on its own. But if you want to take it completely over the top, wait until you see how I finish it!
What's inside?
What's inside?
Chunks of real banana
Dark and milk chocolate chips
Peanut butter chips
The cookie itself is packed with banana, chocolate, and peanut butter flavor, all wrapped up in that signature texture: crispy on the outside and soft and fudgy inside.
But we're not stopping there!
Once the cookie has cooled, it's ready for the ultimate Elvis-inspired finish: whipped peanut butter, hot fudge, and a luscious brown sugar banana frosting.
Think creamy peanut butter, rich chocolate, sweet banana, and brown sugar coming together in one seriously decadent cookie.
You can enjoy it straight from the oven or dress it up with all the toppings for the full Elvis experience. Either way, this is one cookie that knows how to make an impression!
TWO INCREDIBLE COOKIES. ONE TUTORIAL.
TWO INCREDIBLE COOKIES. ONE TUTORIAL.
With this tutorial, you'll learn to make my Bananas Foster Sandwich Cookie, my bestselling sandwich cookie for two consecutive years, plus receive the Elvis Cookie bonus recipe.
Whether you're expanding your gourmet cookie collection, baking something extraordinary for friends and family, or adding new flavors to your own baking repertoire, these recipes bring something special to the table.
I believe great cookies are about more than sweetness. They're about texture, balance, and building layers of flavor that make someone stop after the first bite and say, “Oh, my goodness!”
These two cookies do exactly that.
READY TO BAKE SOMETHING UNFORGETTABLE?
READY TO BAKE SOMETHING UNFORGETTABLE?
If you love bold flavors, indulgent fillings, and cookies with that irresistible crispy exterior and soft, fudgy center, this tutorial belongs in your collection.
Get the Bananas Foster Cookie Tutorial and receive the Elvis Cookie bonus recipe!
Two bold, indulgent flavor combinations. Layers of delicious details. And two more cookies worth craving.
Elvis
Bananas Foster
Elvis
Bananas Foster
Page updated
Google Sites
Report abuse